Political Does Not = Good
A lot of people having been talking recently or rather explaining to me how political bands are becoming these days especially with the 2nd win for the bush administration. These people list off bands like Sum 41, Offspring, New Found Glory, Green Day, Mathew Good… well okay Mathew Good was always quite political (he’s an exception to this) but these people are justifying listening to bands because they are quote on quote “political”. No dipshit, it doesn’t work that way there are millions of groups out there that are “political” by stating that "Geroge Bush is a Moron" and entitling a song after that is hardly a deep and meangful political statement, it's about as deep and meangful as me switching the channel during a commercial. These people are just shoving their uninformed opinions down everyones throats with an overly simple an ineffective way of doing it. Garbage.
People seem to forget that because a band is not directly bashing a political figure it does not mean that they don’t have a political standpoint. People tell me how great it is that all these bands are becoming political and are creating “an awareness among their listeners” bullshit. These guys are about as competent of sending a meaningful political message as I am at hockey. And I suck at hockey. Take “The Stampeders” for example “Cherokee Nation” is a beautifully political song about a real world issue that still fucking affects anyone in North America. But does anyone say “yeah I love the Stampeders they are so fucking political now” NO they don’t. instead a million people would probably laugh at that person and tell him/her that they have bad taste in music.
Or better yet Iron Maiden, there are few bands that can compare with Iron Maiden, their stance on war/propaganda/death penalty/First Nation’s rights etc… is almost incomparable…. Except there are few to no fellow 80’s mulleteer’s that would say “fucking rights man! I listen to fucking Iron Maiden because they are sooo political Man!” no. they listen to Iron Maiden because Iron Maiden kicks ass, they don’t justify it with it being political. It is just a givin that they kick ass, the same way that gravity is an active force working on every object at any given time. You don’t fuck with gravity and you don’t fuck with Maiden.
“As the reasons for the carnage cut their meat and lick the gravy, We oil the jaws of the war machine and feed it with our babies.”
Is that not just the most poetic thing you’ve ever read?
“The body bags and little rags of children torn in two And the jellied brains of those who remain to put the finger right on you. As the madmen play on words and make us all dance to their song, To the tune of starving millions to make a better kind of gun.”
Beautiful
Just because a band is political doesn’t mean it is good. Don’t justify your shitty taste in music just because it is anti-bush. The Dixie Chicks were anti bush and it didn’t improve their music by any means so don’t give me that shit.
“The bugle sounds and the charge begins But on this battlefield no one wins The smell of acrid smoke and horses breath As I plunge on into certain death.”
People seem to forget that because a band is not directly bashing a political figure it does not mean that they don’t have a political standpoint. People tell me how great it is that all these bands are becoming political and are creating “an awareness among their listeners” bullshit. These guys are about as competent of sending a meaningful political message as I am at hockey. And I suck at hockey. Take “The Stampeders” for example “Cherokee Nation” is a beautifully political song about a real world issue that still fucking affects anyone in North America. But does anyone say “yeah I love the Stampeders they are so fucking political now” NO they don’t. instead a million people would probably laugh at that person and tell him/her that they have bad taste in music.
Or better yet Iron Maiden, there are few bands that can compare with Iron Maiden, their stance on war/propaganda/death penalty/First Nation’s rights etc… is almost incomparable…. Except there are few to no fellow 80’s mulleteer’s that would say “fucking rights man! I listen to fucking Iron Maiden because they are sooo political Man!” no. they listen to Iron Maiden because Iron Maiden kicks ass, they don’t justify it with it being political. It is just a givin that they kick ass, the same way that gravity is an active force working on every object at any given time. You don’t fuck with gravity and you don’t fuck with Maiden.
“As the reasons for the carnage cut their meat and lick the gravy, We oil the jaws of the war machine and feed it with our babies.”
Is that not just the most poetic thing you’ve ever read?
“The body bags and little rags of children torn in two And the jellied brains of those who remain to put the finger right on you. As the madmen play on words and make us all dance to their song, To the tune of starving millions to make a better kind of gun.”
Beautiful
Just because a band is political doesn’t mean it is good. Don’t justify your shitty taste in music just because it is anti-bush. The Dixie Chicks were anti bush and it didn’t improve their music by any means so don’t give me that shit.
“The bugle sounds and the charge begins But on this battlefield no one wins The smell of acrid smoke and horses breath As I plunge on into certain death.”
10 Comments:
well I will argue this. If a band writes a song about politics, whether it be anti bush or whatever. I'm almost positive that they have strong feelings about it. So don't go and say that bands with political songs don't feel it, because if they really didn't care then they wouldn't write a song about it. Theres lots of shit I don't care about, therefore I don't write songs about them. Also Maiden fucking rules, lyrics, music, everything. Fuck yea Maiden!
By
Clifford, at 2:17 AM
i much prefer it when bands sing about highschool and girls that dumped them
political music = huge step up for most of the bands you mentioned
By
joe, at 12:12 PM
i'm sure they do have strong feelings for anti-bush...
but i'm just saying two things
1) they lack the finesse that other rock/metal and punk bands had before them in giving a meaningful political message.
2) there are millions of bands out there that are political, but no one justifies listening to maiden because they are political. they listen to them because they kick ass.
i feel that these bands are jumping onto an unorginal bandwagon, i beleive this mainly because all these problems in society existed long before the bush administration took over and it will happen again and again in the future.
"Great satan, our flags are burning
Now America has found its young men
In the sand
Where their casualty
Is just another number
In Iraq"
-Offspring
i'm sorry but this is garbage, it's a good try but it has nothing on other political bands.
By
Doc, at 2:22 PM
yea but offspring have done nothing but eat cock after Americana. There are plently of good new political songs, can't think of any right now, nor do I care to find a particular one, but they're out there. And there are also shitty political old songs too. So we'll just say, there was good music in the past, there was shitty music in the past, there is good music now, and there is shitty music now. Thats the way it will always be. People say that there is rarely good music these days, but thats only because your looking at whats out right now, when you look at the pasat your looking at decades of music, theres bound to be a flower amoungst the shit, and when you add more shit, you'll get more flowers. I tried making it make more sense, but It didn't work that good, but if you don't understand it then I hate you.
By
Clifford, at 2:44 PM
exactly, hordes of great bands were political
The Who, The Beatles, the Clash, - i'm talking rock giants here.
besides, its a big deal, so artists are going to think about it, meaning they are going to write about it
By
joe, at 3:33 PM
exactly, hordes of great bands were political
Hey Joel, he's saying that it's moving from "...hordes of great bands were political" to "hordes of political bands are great." Notice the difference?
By
Anonymous, at 9:07 PM
hordes of politcal bands ARE great
he's just writing off anyone who writes anything political, actually, which is stupid because lots of bands, including some he cites as being among the best of rock, were also political.
thats the difference, cheif.
By
joe, at 10:32 PM
"Just because a band is political doesn’t mean it is good. Don’t justify your shitty taste in music just because it is anti-bush"
was the point i made
By
Doc, at 5:05 PM
actually i got more of "if a band is political then it sucks" vibe from that post
but either way
By
joe, at 10:38 PM
MEIN FRIENDHUND LIEPEN!!!!
By
Anonymous, at 6:40 PM
Post a Comment
<< Home